I can accept this from Coyne: >> Anthony Cashmore: >> "Free will is defined as a belief that there is a component to biological behavior that is something more than the unavoidable consequences of the genetic and environmental history of the individual and the possible stochastic laws of nature.-Funnily enough when I first discussed free will on this forum, people on insisted that we had consciousness in the definition.-Either way by Cashmore's definition do you think we have free will?