All I am proposing, and I can't imagine what is in Krause's mind, Fair enough > is that there has never been a true nothing, that some sort of energy must be eternal, because it is impossible to get something from a true nothing. Since the universe has a complex interactive zoo of quantum particles, an intelligence put that together to work to form a universe which supports life. I'm simply working backward from what we know. I think his definition does not take this view into account, because his thinking is that he must maintain an atheist position. By starting with a quantum potentiality, he can use it to perturb his way to this universe, making it all chance, no teleology. My view is I cannot conceive of the result of sentient humans as a chance phenomenon.-So when we strip away all of a materialist something we are left with god? [For you]-When we strip away all of a materialist something we are left with a quantum event? [For a quantum scientist]