I posted a link to this thread in the comments on the "Nirmulka" article, but the authors decilned to come to this forum to respond. However, they have responded to a shortened version that I posted into their comments. You will need to access the article to read their replies.-One of the responses links to this article on Austin Cline's blog "About Atheism". It is a direct critique of the "Agnostic's Brief Guide", and something of a personal attack on DHW.-http://atheism.about.com/b/2008/01/23/dh-wilsons-guide-to-agnostic-arrogance-ignorance.htm-It is dated January last year (2008) so may have been noted here before, but is new to me. There is a comment at the end (10) by a Tom Haze that tries to defend DHW's position, but Cline responds by referring him to the associated discussion forum.