You've really got it bad with Dawkins haven't you! > > Its not just me. So do English folks like Melanie Phillips in the Spectator: http://www.spectator.co.uk/melaniephillips/2543431/is-richard-dawkins-still-evolving.thtml - Needless to say in this article she has obviously misrepresented and or misunderstood Dawkins' views, as is her way. - Melanie Phillips is a controversialist whose statements on anything should be treated as unreliable, e.g. one of her Jewish journalist colleagues writes: - http://www.jonathanfreedland.com/articles/archives/000329.html - She is also strongly anti-science, being an "Intelligent Design" groupie, and an MMR and Global warming sceptic. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melanie_Phillips - I would comment more strongly but don't wish to put dhw in danger of prosecution for libel.