Romansh: She is a psychologist and you are not? She has written a text book on consciousness and you have not? > > Irrelevant > > Having said that I would love to meet her and discuss stuff with her. She seems like an interesting and lively person with a whole bunch of different views. > > I always wondered about posts like these. If she were a member of this forum would you actually write what you do?-I would ask her outright, why she offered differing opinions on medical findings by physician authors. She may be a psychologist, but as an internist I had training in psychiatry and using it. I'll take her on any day. In my last book, I spent a good part of a chapter using her as the resident skeptic and chewing up her observations.